Types of Metal Roofing Materials – Pros and Cons

Metal roofing in Ontario is long-lasting with a lifespan of up to sixty years, highly resistant to corrosion and the roughest of Canadian weather, and environmentally friendly. Steel, aluminum, and copper are the three most popular metal roofing materials selected for residential and commercial application. Though we think of ‘metal roofing’ being a steel roof, there are some options. Please feel encouraged to browse below for more information on the different types of metal roofing materials, and their respective pros and cons.


Steel is the most popular metal roofing material in Canada, being selected by the vast majority of homeowners for their properties. Steel itself has several options with is definitely a pro when trying to pair it with the aesthetic of a home. Though initially used more as a commercial roofing product, steel is more common in residential settings today as it’s highly adaptable from an aesthetic standpoint. Another pro to steel is that it has a high recyclability rating and the availability of recycled steel means that a lot of what we use to make steel roofing is from recycled sources. Steel is the least expensive metal roofing product in Canada and is one of the most recycled materials in the world.


Aluminum is long-lasting similar to steel and boasts high resistance to salt water corrosion. Aluminum is perfect for saltier regions and coastal climates. That said, its durability is slightly lower than steel and other metals. The downside to aluminum is that it is costlier than steel. Then again, you get what you pay for. Aluminum’s strength to weight ratio is higher than steel. If one does decide to go with an aluminum metal roof, it’s important to speak with the roofing contractor to determine whether it’s the most appropriate option for your region and where your property is situated.


Copper is a less popular metal roofing material these days but it’s been used for centuries. Copper can last up to two hundred years, are 100% recyclable, soft, and with a low melting temperature, copper makes for a good high-performance roof. The softness of copper means that it does not produce much noise when it rains however it is prone to hail damage. These roof bends may not be the most aesthetically pleasing but they themselves show a resilient roof. A major con of copper roofing is that it is very, very expensive which for most Canadian households, will put it out of consideration for a metal roof replacement.

Choose what’s right for your property

Finding a metal roofing contractor who is experienced and knowledgeable about metal roofing products may have a recommendation to provide. If not, choose what’s right and most appropriate for your needs.

Steel, aluminum, and copper all have their place however depending on the budget for one’s roof replacement and the specific requirements of the region a property is set in, one may be more inclined to go with one over the others.

metal roof material

Every metal roofing material comes with its advantages. Copper is one of the most aesthetically pleasing however it is the most soft and expensive. Aluminum is great for certain regions of Canada and is less expensive than copper. Then, steel is less expensive, more affordable, and delivers a powerful punch of a performance you’ll love. Choose the metal listening to the roofing contractor you choose, the location of the build, and any other considerations your property may have.

Which one is Better for your Home: Comparing Aluminum and Steel Roofing

Two of the most popular roofing materials used in Ontario are aluminum and steel. If you are not sure which material is appropriate for your property, comparing the advantages and disadvantages of aluminum and steel roofing can help better inform your decision.

The Pros and Cons of Aluminum

There are many reasons to choose aluminum over steel. For example, aluminum is more corrosion resistant. Aluminum is more expensive however which may not make it appropriate for some buyers. Despite its high price, the quality is worth it to some. Aluminum has a long life, offers a high level of protection, and is a far better selection than the traditional asphalt which will lose its protective ability over time. Contrary to popular belief, noise is not an issue if your aluminum roof has been correctly installed. Also, those that are concerned with its aesthetic appearance can be assured that aluminum is typically sold with a painted surface in order to increase its curb appeal. Much like steel, aluminum roofing in Ontario is easily installed and is among the lightest metals used for roofing.

Comparing Aluminum and Steel Roofing

The Pros and Cons of Steel

There are many families and property owners in Ontario who have chosen steel over aluminum and for a number of different reasons. Steel is more fire resistant without underlayment and is less expensive, making it a popular choice among buyers who are seeking an affordable roofing option. Steel roofing also has a long life, offers a high level of protection, and comes in a range of different styles and colors that can help to make your roofing camouflage with its surroundings. In addition, noise from hail, rain or snow is not an issue with steel either if it is correctly installed. Throughout the past decade, steel roofing in Ontario has become more common than aluminum for these reasons and is highly sought after for its value. If you are a first-time buyer of metal roofing, steel as a material may provide the biggest bang for your buck and is a more affordable choice than aluminum.

Is Steel or Aluminum Better for Roofing

When you compare steel roofing and aluminum roofing, weighing the pros and cons show that these are two similar but distinct options. As metal roofing in Ontario has continued to grow in popularity, there are some contractors who might argue aluminum to be a better choice than steel roofing. There are other contractors that may argue steel to be a better material.

It is ultimately up to the consumer to decide what is more appropriate for their property. If you are upgrading to a new metal roofing system, you need to invest in the right roof, not the cheapest. Though aluminum does have its advantages, many customers have chosen to go with steel roofing due to the lower cost as well as the diverse range of color and style options available. If you are unsure of what roofing material is best for your residential or commercial property, please be sure to contact us directly to find out more information on what metal roofing material is best for your property.